Increase on Navigational Incidents and Collisions

A few days ago the  Standard P&I Club issued a safety bulletin regarding Navigational Incidents and Collisions. The Standard P&I Club has investigated the number and cost of navigational incidents over the past ten years and the facts are alarming at many levels. In the past five years, there have been 85 claims of over $1m of which over 50% were directly related to navigational issues.

Of these claims:

  1. 42% were due to collisions,
  2. 32% were due to damaging fixed and floating objects such as buoys, berths, breakwaters, mooring dolphins and cranes, and
  3. 15% were due to ships grounding.

Of the above major incidents, 16% occurred when the ship was under pilotage.

This is a significant figure and the inference could be that either the pilots are not well trained or the master and the bridge teams are not properly monitoring what is happening when under pilotage, or a combination of both. Only occasionally is the cause of a navigational incident a mechanical failure.

This issue of Standard Safety is focused solely on navigation. Claims relating to poor navigation are the largest single cause of claims in terms of cost, and the club’s experience in recent years provides ample evidence of this. A number of factors are investigated using case studies to illustrate the problems and consider what can be done to curb the increasing frequency of navigational incidents.

There are many such case studies available, some of which are published by
Flag States and are in the public domain. These, we believe, should form part of a company’s loss prevention programme since it is far better to learn from the mistakes of others than experience them yourself. The biggest risk that a shipowner faces is a major navigational incident: not only can it result in fatalities and pollution but can have a substantial impact on the reputations of those concerned.

For more information, regarding Standard’s Safety special edition on Navigation please click here.

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: