Chief Officer Pleads Guilty to Causing Grounding

On 2nd July 2012 the Antigua and Barbuda registered cargo ship Coastal Isle was en route from Belfast to Greenock when at 0500hrs in the morning it grounded at Garroch Point on the southern coast of the Island of Bute. The vessel grounded due to the fact that the chief officer on watch left the bridge to go to the toilet.

2013.01.23 - Chief Officer Pleads Guilty to Causing Grounding

There was a crew of ten onboard the ship but fortunately there were no injuries and there was no pollution. The ship was refloated at around 09.30hours the same day and proceeded to Greenock where divers found that the ship had suffered serious damage for about one third of its length and the fore peak tank was ruptured.

The Chief Officer, Necati Izmir admitted leaving the bridge at about 03.00hrs to go to the toilet and has no recollection of events until after the collision when he was found in his cabin by the second officer who had been sent to look for him

The Captain, Bernd Radel from Germany stated that the Chief Officer had been found asleep in his bed. Izmir pleaded guilty at the Sheriff Court in Greenock on 23rd November 2012 to failing to safely navigate his ship.

Sentencing Mr Izmir on Tuesday 22nd January, the Sheriff Mrs Anderson fined Mr Izmir a total of £5,000.

Captain Singh Grewal, Area Operations Manager (Survey and Inspection) for the MCA stated: This was a very serious incident. It could so easily have been a dreadful tragedy but fortunately there were no injuries or pollution.

Source: MCA


  1. Capt. Shakeeb Obaid says:

    The vast majority of the accidnts at sea are manily attributed to the neglect & carelessness of the duty officer ie the OOW…and must be punished severely for the sake of the likely innocent victims!

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: